Summary: If there’s one thing Konrad Curze and the Night Haunter can agree on, it’s that they both want the same person. (No Nails AU, Guilliman/Curze, early in the AU, PG-13)
***
Konrad Curze was very good at making himself unhappy. He caged away the monster, but he also wrapped himself in chains. Morality, social expectations, things a good person was supposed to do or not do, things you were supposed to take for granted. He wanted things he thought he wasn’t supposed to, wasn’t allowed to, and had to fight moment by moment to keep the monster inside when what the monster wanted was what he really wanted.
The Night Haunter didn’t feel the weight of any of that emotional baggage. What it wanted, it did. It enjoyed itself. It was playing a game with the galaxy, for entertainment and to win. It was justice. No complications. No consequences or worry about them, because there was only the moment. Besides, there was very little that could impose consequences on a primarch or stop one.
What it wanted was blood and screaming. Its sheer misanthropic hatred of all that lived made that a symphony to its ears. Then everyone would shut up and it wouldn’t have to hear the buzz of their minds all around with their constant petty venality and excuses.
Really, they all should have been impressed by how many people he didn’t murder everyday. Even when he wanted to. Even when they deserved it.
Not Roboute, Konrad claimed. Different, better, mine. Konrad loved him, wanted him, soaked in him like water in the desert–his presence, the sound of his voice, the touch of his hands, the steadiness at the edge of his mind. Still there was always that little voice that Roboute would tire of him or of humouring his weakness, that he would realise how much better he could do, that the other shoe would drop and he’d find out what Roboute really wanted from him. He could either keep worrying, keep up the distance completely and he couldn’t do that. He wanted to. He wanted to say I love you, I’ll murder anything that tries to hurt you, I’ll give you everything, but he…
The monster agreed in some ways. Roboute was different, not just as a primarch, but because of Konrad’s whole mess of emotions. It didn’t hate him. It found him… interesting. It wanted to play with him, like a cat with a mouse, rather than the all consuming hate and rage that led it to slaughter.
It thought Konrad’s reservations and mistrust were more likely to be right than not and liked to remind him of that, but it didn’t care as much. When (if) Roboute broke Konrad’s hearts, all the king’s horses and all the king’s men wouldn’t be able to put Konrad back together again. Then he would stop trying, stop pretending, and the Night Haunter could do everything.
Until then, it was still simple. Konrad wanted him so the Night Haunter did too, no romance or interest in anyone else’s feelings in its way, just desire.
It was fun to sneak kisses even if it was batted away most of the time. Roboute was uncomfortable and that was funny, and wary enough to treat it like an enemy. Only sensible since everyone was an enemy, some just more cowed than others or too dead to ever be a threat again.
It liked to play with him, like a cat batting a mouse back and forth. Didn’t even have to break his legs first, because noble Guilliman wouldn’t try to run. Konrad’s movements were always jerky, but this creature made each step into a lunge. It was violence and hunger made flesh.
‘Go away and give him back.’
‘No,’ Night Haunter said, going in towards Roboute’s neck and getting held at arm’s reach. It bit his hand and licked at the blood, but Roboute hardly flinched and didn’t let him closer. ‘I see no reason why I should.’
Just a bit too little sleep, too little food week after week over too long and it eventually added up until the cage doors were so brittle they could just
snap.
‘I can think of many. Leave him.’
‘Or what? Will you hurt me ‘til I do?’ it purred. ‘What else are you going to threaten me with?’
‘Don’t think I won’t hurt you because you share the same body.’ Roboute’s hands tightened to try to hold it in place.
‘Will you? He’ll remember. Will you tip your hand and show him you’ll hurt him if he does something you don’t like?’
‘I don’t want him to remember hurting me either, or for him to think I won’t stop him from doing things he doesn’t want to do.’
‘But he does. Or, should I say, I do.’
‘You’re wrong in your assumptions there.’
‘Oh, what’s that?’
‘I don’t think you’re different people.’
Night Haunter laughed. ‘Good ploy. Now we have some privacy where he won’t remember.’ Not that anything would go wrong with Konrad’s eidetic memory, he would simply unconsciously shy away from anywhere too close to here because he couldn’t deal with processing that.
‘I’ve been thinking about it. Do not misunderstand me. You are everything he does not want to be, and he locked you away because he chose not to. You are unusually disassociated from the rest of his personality, but you are a set of impulses everyone has.’
‘The cold administrator wants to hunt and tear them apart with his bare hands and taste the blood on his teeth?’
‘Yes. Sometimes. But I don’t, because I don’t want to more. Being vengeful is easy, but it’s a bad reason to send men to war. I’ve chosen not to do what I feel is wrong, and so has he. That’s why he doesn’t want you.’
Night Haunter grinned. It didn’t care about morals or ethics and had no investment in winning an argument about them. It just wanted to make Roboute uncomfortable, to make him feel guilty or unsure as he sought to justify himself. Everyone justified himself, I was right, I had to, Someone else would have if I didn’t (Night Haunter’s was Because I wanted to and Trying to do otherwise is futile.)
‘Killer of worlds. As long as you did it with regret rather than glee in your hearts. Do the dead care, I wonder, or would they have rather lived?’
Roboute was angry now, Night Haunter could see it in the tense of his muscles and the pulse under his skin. What he said, though, was, ‘Don’t try, monster. You’re no Angron. We left because we had been wrong.’
‘Such a monumental error.’
‘I am a primarch. You say we cannot deny our natures. I believe our nature is this: that everything we do, for good or ill, is by on a grand scale. When we are wrong, worlds burn. Billions, trillions likely, die, or reduced to lives of pain, loss, and meaningless. Yet, even if the galaxy would have been better off without us, we exist and must do our best.’
Roboute had the look on his face he got when he was thinking quickly and intensely, even for him, running through theoreticals and applying practicals by the hundreds every second.
‘Do you want me to say it? I will. The Emperor was wrong in many ways, and we did wrong, both in obeying him and because of our misguided beliefs. I have done things that I now believe were wrong. Many of the compliances were wrong. We destroyed much that was good and worthy in the name of tyranny.
‘Not all of it–there are regimes that need to be pulled down and people who need to be stopped from preying on others. I don’t disagree with everything you’ve said, or we’d have nothing in common. But being a monster for the sake of that which needs done? No. We have more power than that. You have me and I have you. We can do better. We can do it right, without compromise. I seek peace. I will kill if I see no other way to prevent the deaths of others, but with regret and reluctance in my heart. Maybe you will call it hypocrisy, but it matters to me.’
‘So Lawful Good.’
‘I wrote the laws. I could rewrite them. That means the only person I’m answerable to is myself. What being lawful is about is refusal to compromise. Therefore, I must know my own heart and own mind, and what I consider to be good and what evil, and make decisions with my eyes open. I must protect my people, all of them, and treat every life as if it is that of someone I know and love personally, then make decisions on their behalf that will cost some their lives anyway.’
‘How can you love him knowing what he’s done? You’ve heard how they died? How they pleaded for their lives and eventually just for the pain to stop? Knowing how much he enjoyed it? Do all those people he killed not matter to you because he’s your brother? Because you want him? Forgive him anything because they didn’t matter as much as he does, or do you agree that they deserved it?’ The monster bit as its tongue as it talked, remembering the taste of blood and wanting more of it.
‘I saw the inside of his head, remember. I can understand, I can accept, I can love, even that which I can’t forgive. I can admire him for what he tried to do and what he built from nothing. I can see the goodness in him, the righteousness. Justice is personal, for it to be true, about who someone has chosen to be, not guilt by association on a large scale.
‘I can also say he was wrong in methods, and lost his way, and I disagree with him. He tried to harness you to do what he thought had to be done. He was wrong; you can’t be used. You can’t be used in degrees according to someone else’s will; you destroy everything you touch, including him. I can stand here and offer him another path and support him in his choice to walk it.’
‘Pretty words for the dead. Plenty of people have offered philosophy for how things should be while he ate their children.’
‘I’m not perfect and never claimed to be. I’m not a saint, I don’t belong on a pedestal. So love is something selfish. So I too find suffering easy to ignore when it’s happening to strangers I don’t have to see or know. What is justice? More killing will not bring back the dead. We must live for the future, and choose how to live the rest of our lives since we are here.’
‘You can’t protect everyone like that. You are weak. Those who sin will do so again.’
‘I know I can’t. I will fail over and over and others will suffer for it. Yet I will protect what I can, every time. The world isn’t as cruel as you make it out to be.’
‘How do you justify everything you’ve seen that contradicts that?’
‘Love. Truth. Faith. I do not deny the existence of evil, so don’t deny the existence of good.’
Konrad thought the monster thought only about violence. It would freely admit it usually thought about killing, but it was more than that. The monster didn’t do evil for the sake of evil. It did evil because it enjoyed it. Because of the righteousness of it. There were all manner of vices that existed that it had never indulged in; not because it resisted temptation, but because it didn’t find them tempting, or remotely interesting. It did the things Konrad wanted to do but wouldn’t, because of reasons or it would be wrong or some such restraint of another. Wanting to lash out, to make them pay, make them suffer, keep them from ever hurting anyone with their malice and their greed and their pettiness ever again was the background noise of his life, and when he was Konrad he usually didn’t unless he could give himself an excuse.
The situation was unprecedented, admittedly. Konrad wanted to kill most people, most of the time. He pre-emptively hated and distrusted people far away he hadn’t met yet. At best he found people less annoying than most, or more easily cowed and tamed. Liking someone, loving someone, to this degree not something that fit into his worldview. The entire rest of the galaxy might be in one category to him, but Roboute was in another.
Night Haunter was just a dark mirror. Only a reflection, nothing new. It was Konrad Curze without restraint, without reason, without justification, without the chains of not doing things a good person wasn’t supposed to do or want to do. Konrad was afraid of hurting him, but that was experience telling him he was the kind of person who liked hurting people and always had done it before. But even the Night Haunter did not act with complete randomness; it was only that Konrad refused to examine his own motives and emotions closely enough to understand the underlying logic.
Konrad mistrusted Roboute, couldn’t believe in something that seemed too good to be true without wanting to poke and prod and find the imperfections and betrayals beneath. Konrad, even in the darkest depths of his hearts or in momentary flashes of irritation that he didn’t really mean even at the time, really and truly did not want to kill Roboute. So Night Haunter didn’t either.
Simple.
So the Night Haunter loved him. So the Night Haunter kissed him.
‘Can you stop me from fucking you without hurting your boyfriend?’
‘No.’ Roboute’s fingers tightened on him with deliberation more than passion, but tighter than he would hold Konrad. The grip was a threat. That wasn’t right. He should want the monster outside, believing he was safe. Shouldn’t want to keep it here, to be trapped with it. ‘You and me. You think there’s a theoretical I’ll let you hurt me rather than hurt you. Do you think that exists for anyone else under my protection while I’m here to stop you?’
No, it didn’t. It had met him. Honestly, it wasn’t half as interested in anyone else as it was in Roboute. It wondered if it could make Konrad’s gentle lover get rough. It wasn’t tentative and easily led like Konrad was, and Roboute wasn’t as indulgent of the monster. It wanted Roboute to try to stop it, but not succeed. It wanted, it wanted, it wanted.
‘Tire me out enough and I’ll crawl back to my den to sleep. He wants to throw you down and despoil you and make you as dirty as him and he hates himself for it.’
‘Sex isn’t dirty, whatever your planet taught you. I’m not ashamed of wanting him.’ There was a slight hint of the embarrassed blush Roboute was prone to, but no hesitation or wavering in his voice. ‘I want him to be safe and happy more.’
It knew about wanting. It allowed itself to be distracted with games, but it did fully intend to take what it wanted. It didn’t have any of those pesky ‘Should I? Should I not?’ steps between wanting and doing. Wanted to make him squirm and scream and…
Roboute held its head in place and kissed it gently despite Night Haunter’s attempts to bite back, then carded his fingers through its hair. ‘I love you.’
He was dangerous because he made it want to feel feelings, Konrad feelings. Wanting to have someone was easy. Wanting someone to be happy and to burn everything that might ever threaten them was the kind of complicated it didn’t handle. It couldn’t think–it was immediacy, animal impulses, raw emotions. I would do terrible things for you. ‘That’s what people always say when they want to fuck for free.’
Roboute didn’t get defensive or back down. ‘If you want me, I’m here. If you want me to stop, I will. Whatever Konrad remembers of this, he has nothing to be ashamed of, because I said yes and meant it.’ His touches were light, soothing. They made Night Haunter fidget with stopped-up energy.
It wasn’t hesitant in taking the initiative. It ground its hips against him. Its claws tore bloody stripes in Roboute’s chest through his robes. It pushed him into his coach and loomed over him.
Roboute didn’t flinch and didn’t back down, and let the Night Haunter do all that without losing a fraction of his control. As he was pushed down, and he reached up and pulled the Night Haunter to him just as firmly.
‘I love you. I believe in you. I won’t look away no matter what I see, no matter what happens. I love everything about you, even the parts of you that you hate, though I support you in wanting to change. Even if I had to kill you someday, I won’t look away, because I love you.’
It might not have sounded reassuring to anyone else, but Konrad thought, Thank you. He wouldn’t have believed him in statements like That will never happen or I’ll never give up on you. What comforted him was knowing someone would stop him if he lost himself.
Roboute couldn’t have made a monster fall in love with him, because that would be stupid, but the fact was Konrad Curze had fallen in love with him and the monster was one in the same.
It was frustrating how even being firm he managed to be gentle. He was holding it tightly enough Konrad would have been having a panic attack, but not tight enough, Night Haunter thought. It should hurt, the bones of its wrists grinding together until they broke. But Roboute wasn’t doing that, wouldn’t do that. Still trying to stop it without hurting it. Trying to kiss it softly even as it bit him back. He wouldn’t meet violence with violence because he was weak (in love), and it made Night Haunter want to scream with conflicting emotions and kill until they went away.
Why would he do that when he knew it was a monster?
Because that was the choice he had made, to make love to a monster and in doing so declare it human, because that which was worthy of love could not by definition be a monster.
With his lover beneath him, smiling and satiated and radiant as surely as he was bruised and bloody and well-used, the Night Haunter couldn’t fight Konrad rising to the forefront of their mind again, because Roboute was something he wanted to come back to. Roboute had said he loved him again and again without fear or lies, until Konrad could almost believe he had nothing to be ashamed of for what he had just done to him.
With the future silent, he could hear himself think, and be Konrad and not the monster.